Opinion

You can’t schedule the good part

You can’t schedule the good part_feature: graphic illustration of older convertible car with people driving out of pocket-watch with flower inside
Generated by Dan Warren using Gemini

“It’s only six sounds.”
— Pharrell Williams, on the beat for Clipse’s “Grindin’”

“Play is guided by mental rules … but the rules always leave room for creativity.”
— Peter Gray

Dr Dan_Pass the mic_series: graphic with man in baseball hat and glasses with "Dr. Dan" at the top and "Pass the Mic" at the bottomYears ago, while working at Scouting America’s National Jamboree, I asked Scouts what had made Scouting special to them.

It seemed like a reasonable question to ask there. The Jamboree is held at the Summit Bechtel Reserve, a camp with epic zip lines, whitewater rafting, mountain biking, a professional-level skate park and miles of trails. I expected the Scouts to tell me about one of those spectacular experiences.

Instead, Scouts repeatedly told me about ordinary weekend camping trips. One described how it rained the whole time and he and his friends spent hours trying to throw a water bottle over a tree branch.

I was fascinated. Here he was, surrounded by some of the most advanced outdoor programming in the world, and the story that explained what Scouting meant to him involved a branch, a bottle and a whole lot of time to fill.

I have thought about that answer ever since.

Six sounds

The story came back to me while listening to Pharrell Williams describe the making of Clipse’s “Grindin’.” In 2002, Pharrell and Chad Hugo, aka the Neptunes, were exploring a minimalist approach. Pharrell was experimenting with how much he could remove while maintaining the feeling he wanted. The finished beat contained only six sounds.

The Neptunes accomplished what they set out to do … and more. The rhythm was immediately recognizable and simple enough to reproduce without instruments or special training. Soon, schools echoed with young people pounding it on cafeteria tables, desks and lockers. A professionally produced record had become something a group of friends could physically enter and perform together.

The Neptunes created the beat. Young people discovered other experiences it could hold. Simplicity sparked creativity.

That is the limit of what anyone can design in advance. We can create time, establish boundaries and give people a way into an experience. We cannot determine what they will make of it. The value of the experience emerges as people begin making choices, responding to one another and discovering possibilities that were never part of the plan.

Good designs leave room for surprise.

The space between

Jazz musicians understand how people can operate together inside that kind of generous space. Saxophonist Steve Lacy remembered Thelonious Monk telling him, “Let some things go by” and “Don’t play everything.” Lacy came to understand that what he did not play could be as important as what he did.

Jazz improvisation begins with a shared structure. Musicians may agree on a composition, tempo and chord progression. Once the music starts, they listen to what is developing around them. They decide when to enter, when to respond and when another person’s idea needs room. The structure allows the music to become something none of them could have created alone.

Herbie Hancock experienced this while performing with Miles Davis. Hancock played a chord that sounded completely wrong to him. Davis listened and played notes that made the chord fit what the band was creating. Something that could have stopped the performance became part of the music.

“Grindin’” shows how someone can create an opening.

Jazz musicians show how people can listen, respond and build something together once they are inside it.

Containers with potential

Generous space does not need to be elaborate. A few clear boundaries can be more engaging than a completed structure.

This may explain why a child ignores an expensive present and spends hours playing with its box. The toy has more features, but adults have already decided what most of those features do. A box has walls, edges and a defined space while leaving its purpose unresolved. It can become a spaceship, store, castle or hiding place.

The Scout with the water bottle had found another container with potential: a rainy afternoon, some friends and nothing more pressing to do. No adult would put “throw a water bottle over a branch for several hours” on a program schedule. But adults did support the opportunity for Scouts to gather outdoors on a rainy day. Within that generous space, Scouts created their own challenge, rules and shared language.

Because nobody had predetermined the value of the time, they had to make value together.

Quality time takes quantity

Adults often demonstrate care through addition. We add activities, instructions, educational objectives and carefully timed moments of engagement. Eventually, our efforts to provide quality time mean there is nowhere left for a young person to enter.

The most meaningful moments often require quantity time: long stretches in which nothing important appears to be happening. Boredom can (and should) be part of the process. When young people believe it is up to them to fill that space, their engagement belongs to them.

Quantity time does not automatically produce quality. It gives quality somewhere to emerge.

We can schedule the campout. We can provide the place, the people and the time. We should resist creating all the possibilities. The water bottle, the tree branch, the small group and their laughter are the good parts that come from the generous space that follows.

***

Pass the mic: Where hip-hop meets human development. Each month, Daniel Warren, Ph.D., will bring scholars and rappers into dialogue to spark new ways of seeing youth, culture and change. Previous pieces in series:

Dan Warren, Ph.D., is director of youth development and education at Fluent Research. He writes Youth Today’s Pass the Mic column. Warren previously conducted research at Tufts University’s Institute for Applied Research in Youth Development and the National Service Center for the Boy Scouts of America, and spent a decade as an elementary school teacher in the Boston area.

To Top